tea asked . 2021-07-26

Function approximation: Neural network great

Function approximation: Neural network great 'on paper' but when simulated results are very bad?

I need some help with NN because I don't understand what happened. One hidden layer, I=4, H=1:20, O=1. I run each net architecture 10 times with different initial weights (left default initnw). I have in total 34 datasets which were divided 60/20/20 when using Levenberg-Marquadt algorithm. Mse_goal = 0.01*mean(var(t',1)), i calculate NMSE and R^2, choose best R^2, for that check performance of each subsample, check regression plots, check rmse. R^2 is usually around 0,95; R for each subset 0,98... But when I simulate network with completely new set of data, estimations deviate quite a lot. It is not because of extrapolation. Data are normalized with mapminmax, transfer functions tansig, purelin.
 
Trainbr was my first choice actually, since I have small dataset and trainbr doesn't need validation set (Matlab2015a), but it is awfully slow. I ran a net with trainbr and we are talking hours versus minutes with trainlm.
 
I've read a ton of Greg Heath's posts and tutorials and found very valuable information there, however, still nothing. I see no way out.
 
 
% Solve an Input-Output Fitting problem with a Neural Network
% Script generated by Neural Fitting app
% Created 09-Aug-2016 18:33:13

% This script assumes these variables are defined:
%
%   MP_UA_K - input data.
%   UA_K - target data.

close all, clear all

load varUA_K

x = MP_UA_K;
t = UA_K;

var_t=mean(var(t',1)); %t variance

[inputs,obs]=size(x); %

hiddenLayerSize = 20; %max number of neurons
numNN = 10; % number of training runs

neurons = [1:hiddenLayerSize]';
training_no = 1:numNN;
obs_no = 1:obs;

nets = cell(hiddenLayerSize,numNN);
trainOutputs = cell(hiddenLayerSize,numNN);
valOutputs = cell(hiddenLayerSize,numNN);
testOutputs = cell(hiddenLayerSize,numNN);
Y_all = cell(hiddenLayerSize,numNN);
performance = zeros(hiddenLayerSize,numNN);
trainPerformance = zeros(hiddenLayerSize,numNN);
valPerformance = zeros(hiddenLayerSize,numNN);
testPerformance = zeros(hiddenLayerSize,numNN);
e = zeros(numNN,obs);
e_all = cell(hiddenLayerSize,numNN);
NMSE = zeros(hiddenLayerSize,numNN);
r_train = zeros(hiddenLayerSize,numNN);
r_val = zeros(hiddenLayerSize,numNN);
r_test = zeros(hiddenLayerSize,numNN);
r = zeros(hiddenLayerSize,numNN);
Rsq = zeros(hiddenLayerSize,numNN);

for j=1:hiddenLayerSize

      % Choose a Training Function
      % For a list of all training functions type: help nntrain
      % 'trainlm' is usually fastest.
      % 'trainbr' takes longer but may be better for challenging problems.
      % 'trainscg' uses less memory. Suitable in low memory situations.
      trainFcn = 'trainbr';  % Bayesian Regularization backpropagation.

      % Create a Fitting Network
      net = fitnet(j,trainFcn);

      % Choose Input and Output Pre/Post-Processing Functions
      % For a list of all processing functions type: help nnprocess
      net.input.processFcns = {'removeconstantrows','mapminmax'};
      net.output.processFcns = {'removeconstantrows','mapminmax'};

      % Setup Division of Data for Training, Validation, Testing
      % For a list of all data division functions type: help nndivide
      % podaci su sortirani prema zavisnoj varijabli, cca svaki tre?i dataset je
      % testni
      net.divideFcn = 'divideind';  % Divide data by index
      net.divideMode = 'sample';  % Divide up every sample
      net.divideParam.trainInd = [1:3:34,2:3:34];
  %     net.divideParam.valInd = [5:5:30];
      net.divideParam.testInd = [3:3:34];

      mse_goal = 0.01*var_t;

      % Choose a Performance Function
      % For a list of all performance functions type: help nnperformance
      net.performFcn = 'mse';  % Mean Squared Error
      net.trainParam.goal = mse_goal;

      % Choose Plot Functions
      % For a list of all plot functions type: help nnplot
      net.plotFcns = {'plotperform','plottrainstate','ploterrhist', ...
          'plotregression', 'plotfit'};

      for i=1:numNN
        % Train the Network
        net = configure(net,x,t);
        disp(['No. of hidden nodes '  num2str(j)  ', Training ' num2str(i) '/' num2str(numNN)])
        [nets{j,i}, tr{j,i}] = train(net,x,t);

        y = nets{j,i}(x);

        e (i,:) = gsubtract(t,y);
        e_all{j,i}= e(i,:);

        trainTargets = t .* tr{j,i}.trainMask{1};
        %valTargets = t .* tr{j,i}.valMask{1};
        testTargets = t .* tr{j,i}.testMask{1};

        trainPerformance(j,i) = perform(net,trainTargets,y);
        %valPerformance(j,i) = perform(net,valTargets,y);
        testPerformance(j,i) = perform(net,testTargets,y);

        performance(j,i)= perform(net,t,y);

        rmse_train(j,i)=sqrt(trainPerformance(j,i));
        %rmse_val(j,i)=sqrt(valPerformance(j,i));
        rmse_test(j,i)=sqrt(testPerformance(j,i));
        rmse(j,i)=sqrt(performance(j,i));

        % outputs of all networks
        Y_all{j,i}= y;

        trainOutputs {j,i} = y .* tr{j,i}.trainMask{1};
        %valOutputs {j,i} = y .* tr{j,i}.valMask{1};
        testOutputs {j,i} = y .* tr{j,i}.testMask{1};

        [r(j,i)] = regression(t,y);
        [r_train(j,i)] = regression(trainTargets,trainOutputs{j,i});
        %[r_val(j,i)] = regression(valTargets,valOutputs{j,i});
        [r_test(j,i)] = regression(testTargets,testOutputs{j,i});

        NMSE(j,i) = mse(e_all{j,i})/mean(var(t',1)); % normalized mse

        % coefficient of determination
        Rsq(j,i) = 1-NMSE(j,i);

      end

      [minperf_train,I_train] = min(trainPerformance',[],1);
      minperf_train = minperf_train';
      I_train = I_train';

%     [minperf_val,I_valid] = min(valPerformance',[],1);
%     minperf_val = minperf_val';
%     I_valid = I_valid';

      [minperf_test,I_test] = min(testPerformance',[],1);
      minperf_test = minperf_test';
      I_test = I_test';

      [minperf,I_perf] = min(performance',[],1);
      minperf = minperf';
      I_perf = I_perf';

      [maxRsq,I_Rsq] = max(Rsq',[],1);
      maxRsq = maxRsq';
      I_Rsq = I_Rsq';

      [train_min,train_min_I] = min(minperf_train,[],1);

%     [val_min,val_min_I] = min(minperf_val,[],1);

      [test_min,test_min_I] = min(minperf_test,[],1);

      [perf_min,perf_min_I] = min(minperf,[],1);

      [Rsq_max,Rsq_max_I] = max(maxRsq,[],1);

end

figure(4)
hold on
xlabel('observation no.')
ylabel('targets')
scatter(obs_no,trainTargets,'b')
% scatter(obs_no,valTargets,'g')
scatter(obs_no,testTargets,'r')
hold off

figure(5)
hold on
xlabel('neurons')
ylabel('min. performance')
plot(neurons,minperf_train,'b',neurons,minperf_test,'r',neurons,minperf,'k')
hold off

figure(6)
hold on
xlabel('neurons')
ylabel('max Rsq')
scatter(neurons,maxRsq,'k')
hold off

% View the Network
%view(net)

% Plots
% Uncomment these lines to enable various plots.
%figure, plotperform(tr)
%figure, plottrainstate(tr)
%figure, ploterrhist(e)
%figure, plotregression(t,y)
%figure, plotfit(net,x,t)

% Deployment
% Change the (false) values to (true) to enable the following code blocks.
% See the help for each generation function for more information.

save figure(4).fig
save figure(5).fig
save figure(6).fig

if (false)
    % Generate MATLAB function for neural network for application
    % deployment in MATLAB scripts or with MATLAB Compiler and Builder
    % tools, or simply to examine the calculations your trained neural
    % network performs.
    genFunction(net,'nn_UA_K_BR');
    y = nn_UA_K_BR(x);
end

% sa?uvati sve varijable iz workspacea u poseban file za daljnju analizu
save ws_UA_K_BR

neural networks , generalization , trainbr , trainlm , simulation , matlab

Expert Answer

Prashant Kumar answered . 2024-12-21 01:58:08

% I need some help with NN because I don't understand what happened. One % hidden layer, I=4, H=1:20, O=1. I run each net architecture 10 times % with different initial weights (left default initnw). I have in total % 34 datasets
 
 
 Do you mean data points N = 34?
It typically takes ~ 10 to 30 data points per dimension to
 
adequately characterize a distribution. For a 4-D distribution I'd recommend
 
 40 <~ Ntrn <~ 120

% which were divided 60/20/20 when using Levenberg-Marquadt

 Ntrn = 34-2*round(0.2*34) = 20

 Hub = (20-1)/(4+1+1) = 3.2

indicating you really don't have enough data to adequately characterize a 4-D distribution.

You should consider

 1. Dimensionality reduction
 2. k-fold crossvalidation
 3. Adding new data with the same mean and covariance (stdv + 
correlations) matrix
% algorithm. Mse_goal = 0.01*mean(var(t',1)), i calculate NMSE and R^2, % choose best R^2, for that check performance of each subsample, check % regression plots, check rmse. R^2 is usually around 0,95; R for each % subset 0,98... But when I simulate network with completely new set of % data, estimations deviate quite a lot. It is not because of % extrapolation.
 
 
 No. It probably is. Your training data subset is insufficiently 
large for 4 dimensions.

 I would begin with minimizing H with dividetrain. Then consider 
k-fold crossvalidation.
% Data are normalized with mapminmax, transfer functions tansig, % purelin. % Trainbr was my first choice actually, since I have small dataset and % trainbr doesn't need validation set (Matlab2015a), but it is awfully % slow. I ran a net with trainbr and we are talking hours versus minutes % with trainlm.
This may be a BUG. Let MATLAB know. What version are you using?
>> ver
% I've read a ton of Greg Heath's posts and tutorials and found very % valuable information there, however, still nothing. I see no way out.
 It typically takes ~ 10 to 30 data points per dimension to adequately 
characterize a distribution,
I suggest calculating the means and stdv for each data set to see how 
much your training data is representative of the total 4-D 
distribution that includes the new datasets. 2 or 3-D 
color coded projections may be helpful.

 


Not satisfied with the answer ?? ASK NOW

Frequently Asked Questions

MATLAB offers tools for real-time AI applications, including Simulink for modeling and simulation. It can be used for developing algorithms and control systems for autonomous vehicles, robots, and other real-time AI systems.

MATLAB Online™ provides access to MATLAB® from your web browser. With MATLAB Online, your files are stored on MATLAB Drive™ and are available wherever you go. MATLAB Drive Connector synchronizes your files between your computers and MATLAB Online, providing offline access and eliminating the need to manually upload or download files. You can also run your files from the convenience of your smartphone or tablet by connecting to MathWorks® Cloud through the MATLAB Mobile™ app.

Yes, MATLAB provides tools and frameworks for deep learning, including the Deep Learning Toolbox. You can use MATLAB for tasks like building and training neural networks, image classification, and natural language processing.

MATLAB and Python are both popular choices for AI development. MATLAB is known for its ease of use in mathematical computations and its extensive toolbox for AI and machine learning. Python, on the other hand, has a vast ecosystem of libraries like TensorFlow and PyTorch. The choice depends on your preferences and project requirements.

You can find support, discussion forums, and a community of MATLAB users on the MATLAB website, Matlansolutions forums, and other AI-related online communities. Remember that MATLAB's capabilities in AI and machine learning continue to evolve, so staying updated with the latest features and resources is essential for effective AI development using MATLAB.

Without any hesitation the answer to this question is NO. The service we offer is 100% legal, legitimate and won't make you a cheater. Read and discover exactly what an essay writing service is and how when used correctly, is a valuable teaching aid and no more akin to cheating than a tutor's 'model essay' or the many published essay guides available from your local book shop. You should use the work as a reference and should not hand over the exact copy of it.

Matlabsolutions.com provides guaranteed satisfaction with a commitment to complete the work within time. Combined with our meticulous work ethics and extensive domain experience, We are the ideal partner for all your homework/assignment needs. We pledge to provide 24*7 support to dissolve all your academic doubts. We are composed of 300+ esteemed Matlab and other experts who have been empanelled after extensive research and quality check.

Matlabsolutions.com provides undivided attention to each Matlab assignment order with a methodical approach to solution. Our network span is not restricted to US, UK and Australia rather extends to countries like Singapore, Canada and UAE. Our Matlab assignment help services include Image Processing Assignments, Electrical Engineering Assignments, Matlab homework help, Matlab Research Paper help, Matlab Simulink help. Get your work done at the best price in industry.